Quick Verdict

  • The ICICI Bank Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ wins for everyday spend with a higher base reward rate of 3% compared to 1% on the Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ.
  • For travel and lounge access, the ICICI Emeralde offers unlimited domestic and international lounge visits, surpassing the Adani One’s limited complimentary visits.
  • The Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ is cheaper to hold with a lower annual fee of Rs 5,000 versus Rs 12,499 on the ICICI Emeralde.
  • Pick the Adani One Signature if you prefer occasional travel benefits and a lower fee; choose the ICICI Emeralde Private Metal for premium perks, extensive lounge access, and higher base rewards on daily spend.

Side by Side

DetailAdani One Signature Credit CardⓘICICI Bank Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ
Annual feeRs 5,000Rs 12,499
Joining feeRs 5,000Rs 12,499
Fee waiver on spendRs 2.00 lakhNot recorded
Reward rate1% base, 7% travel, 3.5% utilities3% base, 3% online, dining, travel
Reward typepointspoints
Domestic lounge4 per yearUnlimited
International loungeNoneUnlimited
Forex markup3.5%2%
Best suited fortravel, lounge, rewardspremium, travel, lounge, rewards, forex, shopping

Rewards Compared

On a Rs 10,000 spend benchmark, the Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ yields Rs 100 back at its base reward rate of 1%. However, it shines in specific categories such as travel where the effective return jumps to Rs 700 per Rs 10,000 spent, and utilities with a 3.5% return or Rs 350. This makes the Adani One an attractive option for travel-focused spenders and those with significant utility bills.

In contrast, the ICICI Bank Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ offers a solid base reward rate of 3%, translating to Rs 300 back on Rs 10,000 spent across all categories. Its category rates remain steady at 3% for online, dining, and travel spends, providing consistent rewards without the need to chase specific categories. This makes the ICICI Emeralde ideal for users seeking dependable rewards on everyday and premium spends alike.

Fees Compared

The Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ carries an annual and joining fee of Rs 5,000 each, with a fee waiver if you spend Rs 2.00 lakh annually, which breaks down to around Rs 16,667 per month. This waiver threshold is relatively achievable for frequent users, making it easier to avoid the fee.

The ICICI Bank Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ has a significantly higher joining and annual fee of Rs 12,499 each. There is no fee waiver mentioned, so cardholders must be prepared to pay this premium cost. The head-to-head comparison shows an extra annual fee of Rs 7,499 on the ICICI Emeralde, which requires an additional Rs 3,74,950 in spend to cover the difference through rewards alone. This means the ICICI Emeralde is best suited for high spenders who will leverage its premium benefits.

Which One Should You Pick

Choose the Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ if you are a moderate spender who wants strong travel-related rewards and a more affordable card with achievable fee waivers. It suits those who value occasional domestic lounge access and want to maximize returns on travel and utilities without committing to a high annual fee.

Opt for the ICICI Bank Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ if you prioritize premium benefits like unlimited domestic and international lounge access, lower forex markup at 2%, concierge services, and golf access. This card fits high spenders who want consistent 3% rewards across key categories and are comfortable paying a steep annual fee for luxury perks.

In summary, skip the Adani One if you need unlimited lounge access or a higher base reward rate. Skip the ICICI Emeralde if you cannot justify its hefty fees or do not spend enough to maximize its premium benefits.

What to Check Before You Apply

  • Verify if the lounge access caps or conditions, especially for the Adani One, which offers limited free visits.
  • Understand the redemption value and flexibility of points as both cards use points but details on conversions are important.
  • Carefully calculate the monthly spend required to waive fees on the Adani One to ensure it fits your budget.
  • Consider the impact of forex markup if you frequently transact abroad; the ICICI Emeralde has a 2% markup, lower than Adani One’s 3.5%.
  • Confirm which airport lounges are accessible under each card and whether Priority Pass membership covers your preferred locations.

FAQ

Which card offers better rewards for everyday purchases?+
The ICICI Bank Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ provides a higher base reward rate of 3%, making it better for everyday spend compared to the Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ which offers 1% base rewards.
Is there a fee waiver available on both cards?+
Only the Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ has a fee waiver on annual spends of Rs 2.00 lakh. The ICICI Bank Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ does not specify any fee waiver, so the annual fee applies regardless of spend.
How do the lounge access benefits compare?+
The ICICI Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ offers unlimited domestic and international lounge access, while the Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ provides 4 domestic lounge visits per year and no international lounge access, although it includes Priority Pass membership with some premium upgrades.
What is the forex markup on these cards?+
The Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ charges a 3.5% forex markup on foreign currency transactions, whereas the ICICI Bank Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ has a lower forex markup of 2%, making it more economical for international spenders.
Are there any notable welcome benefits?+
Yes, the Adani One Signature Credit Cardⓘ includes hotel and holiday vouchers worth Rs 2,000 each and a Rs 5,000 flight voucher on Rs 25,000 spend within 60 days. The ICICI Emeralde Private Metal Credit Cardⓘ offers complimentary Taj Epicure and EazyDiner memberships plus 12,500 bonus reward points.