Quick Verdict

  • For everyday spend, both the Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ and the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ offer the same base reward rate, making them equally rewarding for basic purchases.
  • When it comes to travel and lounge access, the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ wins with four complimentary domestic lounge visits per year, while the Canara Bank card offers none.
  • Both cards are lifetime free with no joining or annual fees, so they are equally inexpensive to hold.
  • Choose the Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ if you want a simple, no-frills card focused on rewards without any lounge benefits. Opt for the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ if you value occasional domestic lounge access and welcome benefits alongside your rewards.

Side by Side

DetailCanara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘIDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ
Annual feeNil (lifetime free)Nil (lifetime free)
Joining feeNil (lifetime free)Nil (lifetime free)
Reward rate0.5%0.5%
Reward typePointsPoints
Domestic loungeNone4 per year (spend gate Rs 20,000 monthly)
International loungeNoneNone
Forex markup3%3.5%
Best suited forRewardsLifetime-free, First card, Shopping

Rewards Compared

On a Rs 10,000 spend, both the Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ and the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ earn Rs 50 back in rewards. This equal reward rate means neither card offers an edge purely on the basis of returns from normal spending. Both cards issue points as their reward type, and since their base reward rates are identical, the effective rupee benefit is the same for the general spend category.

Neither card reports enhanced category rewards, so spend in specific segments does not provide additional benefits. However, the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ offers welcome benefits such as a 5% cashback on the first EMI spend up to Rs 1,000 and extra vouchers worth Rs 500 when you spend Rs 5,000 within 30 days of card issuance, which can increase value during the initial usage period.

Fees Compared

Both the Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ and the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ are lifetime free with no joining or annual fees. This makes them equally cost-effective to hold without any mandatory spending thresholds to waive fees. The IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ does require a monthly spend of Rs 20,000 to access domestic lounges, which is a conditional spend gate rather than a fee waiver requirement. The forex markup on foreign currency transactions is 3% for the Canara Bank card and 3.5% for the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ, meaning the former is slightly cheaper for overseas transactions.

Which One Should You Pick

Choose the Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ if you are a rewards-focused spender who prefers a straightforward, no-fee card without the need for lounge access or other frills. Its slightly lower forex markup also makes it a better option if you occasionally transact abroad.

The IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ is suited for first-time credit card users or shoppers who want a lifetime free card with some additional perks like domestic lounge access and welcome benefits. If you spend Rs 20,000 or more monthly, the lounge access adds value. However, its higher forex markup means it is less attractive for foreign currency spend.

In summary, skip the Canara Bank card if you want lounge access or welcome benefits, and avoid the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ if you want the cheapest forex charges or do not value lounges. For most everyday reward earners, either card will do, but the IDFC card edges ahead for occasional lounge use and first-time users.

What to Check Before You Apply

  • Confirm you can meet the Rs 20,000 monthly spend gate on the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ to fully utilize your four domestic lounge visits per year.
  • Check the redemption process for points on both cards to ensure you get the best value as neither card has enhanced category returns.
  • Understand that both cards waive fees for life but watch for any changes in terms or additional fees in the future.
  • Be aware of the forex markup differences: 3% for Canara Bank and 3.5% for IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ, which affects overseas spend costs.
  • Verify the domestic lounge locations and gate access terms on the IDFC card to ensure they suit your travel patterns.

FAQ

What is the annual fee for both cards?+
Both the Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ and the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ have no annual fee and no joining fee, making them lifetime free cards.
Do these cards offer lounge access?+
Only the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ offers lounge access with four domestic lounges per year, subject to a Rs 20,000 monthly spend gate. The Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ does not provide any lounge access.
How do their reward rates compare?+
Both cards provide a base reward rate of 0.5%, equating to Rs 50 back on Rs 10,000 spent, with no special category enhancements.
Are there any welcome benefits?+
Yes, the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ offers a 5% cashback on the first EMI spend up to Rs 1,000 and additional vouchers worth Rs 500 on spending Rs 5,000 within 30 days. The Canara Bank card does not list any welcome benefits.
Which card is better for foreign currency transactions?+
The Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ has a lower forex markup of 3%, compared to 3.5% for the IDFC First Millennia Card ⓘ, making it marginally cheaper for overseas spend.