Quick Verdict

  • The Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ wins for everyday spend with a higher base reward rate of 0.5%.
  • The SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ leads in dining and grocery categories, offering a 2.5% reward rate, making it better for targeted category spend.
  • Canara Bank’s card is cheaper to hold with no joining or annual fees, while SBI’s card charges Rs 499 for both but offers fee waiver on Rs 1,00,000 annual spend.
  • Choose Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ if you want a no-fee card with consistent rewards on all spend. Opt for SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ if your spend is heavy on dining and groceries and you can meet the fee waiver threshold.

Side by Side

DetailCanara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘSBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ
Annual feeNil (lifetime free)Rs 499
Joining feeNil (lifetime free)Rs 499
Fee waiver on spendRs 1.00 lakh
Reward rate0.5%0.25% base, 2.5% on dining and grocery
Reward typePointsPoints
Domestic loungeNoneNone
International loungeNoneNone
Forex markup3%3.5%
Best suited forRewardsFirst-card, dining, grocery, rewards, shopping

Rewards Compared

The Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ offers a straightforward 0.5% reward rate across all spending. This means on Rs 10,000 spent, you earn Rs 50 back in points, providing a simple and predictable return on everyday expenses without category restrictions.

In contrast, the SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ has a lower base reward rate of 0.25%, translating into Rs 25 for Rs 10,000 spent generally. However, it significantly improves to 2.5% in specific categories like dining and grocery, offering Rs 250 back on Rs 10,000 spent in these areas. This makes SBI Simplysave much more rewarding for users with heavy spend in these categories, but less so for general or diversified spending.

Fees Compared

The Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ is a no-fee card with zero joining and annual fees. This makes it highly cost-effective for users who want to avoid any fee burden.

The SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ charges Rs 499 as both joining and annual fees. However, these fees are waived if you spend Rs 1,00,000 annually, which breaks down to approximately Rs 8,333 monthly. The card’s break-even on base rewards alone requires around Rs 1,99,600 spend to cover the Rs 499 annual fee, making it suitable for users with substantial category spend to justify the fees through enhanced rewards.

Which One Should You Pick

If you prefer a simple, hassle-free card with no fees and consistent rewards on all spending, the Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ is the clear choice. It suits conservative spenders or those new to credit cards who want rewards without commitments or category tracking.

Choose the SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ if your spending pattern is focused on dining and groceries where it offers a very attractive 2.5% reward rate. It is also ideal for first-time cardholders who want the welcome benefits and are comfortable managing the Rs 499 fee with the waiver by maintaining Rs 1,00,000 annual spend.

Skip Canara Bank’s card if you want higher rewards in specific categories, and avoid SBI Simplysave if your spend is low or irregular, as the fees may outweigh the benefits.

What to Check Before You Apply

  • Confirm if reward points have any caps or expiry that could limit value.
  • Check the redemption value of points to ensure they align with your spending goals.
  • Understand the exact spend threshold for fee waiver on SBI Simplysave and assess if you can meet it comfortably.
  • Consider the forex markup charges, 3% for Canara Bank and 3.5% for SBI Simplysave, especially if you travel internationally.
  • Note that neither card offers domestic or international lounge access, so factor this if airport lounge access is important.

FAQ

What is the joining fee for these cards?+
The Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ has no joining fee. The SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ charges Rs 499 as a joining fee.
Is there an annual fee on these cards?+
The Canara Bank card has no annual fee. The SBI Simplysave Credit Card charges Rs 499 annually, but this fee is waived if you spend Rs 1,00,000 annually.
Which card offers better rewards on everyday spending?+
The Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ offers a higher base reward rate of 0.5%, making it better for general spend. SBI Simplysave has a lower base rate but higher rewards in dining and grocery categories.
Do these cards provide airport lounge access?+
Neither card provides domestic or international airport lounge access.
What is the forex markup on these cards?+
The Canara Bank Mastercard Gold Secured Credit Card ⓘ charges 3% forex markup, while SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ charges 3.5%.