Quick Verdict

  • For everyday spend, the Canara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured Credit Card ⓘ wins with a higher base reward rate of 0.5%, earning Rs 50 on Rs 10,000 spent.
  • For dining and grocery spends, the SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ is superior, offering 2.5% rewards, translating to Rs 250 back on Rs 10,000 spent in these categories.
  • The Canara Bank option is cheaper to hold as it has no joining or annual fees, unlike the SBI card which charges Rs 499 each but waives it on Rs 1 lakh annual spend.
  • Choose the Canara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured card ⓘ if you want a fee-free card with some lounge access and decent base rewards; pick SBI Simplysave ⓘ if you spend heavily on dining and groceries and can meet the fee waiver threshold.

Side by Side

DetailCanara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured Credit Card ⓘSBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ
Annual feeNil (lifetime free)Rs 499
Joining feeNil (lifetime free)Rs 499
Fee waiver on spendRs 1.00 lakh
Reward rate0.5%0.25% base; 2.5% dining & grocery
Reward typePointsPoints
Domestic lounge4 per yearNone
International loungeNoneNone
Forex markup3%3.5%
Best suited forRewards, UPI-RuPay, LoungeFirst card, Dining, Grocery, Rewards, Shopping

Rewards Compared

The Canara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured Credit Card ⓘ offers a straightforward base reward rate of 0.5%, which means on Rs 10,000 spent, you earn Rs 50 worth of points. This is a simple, flat rate on all spends, appealing to users looking for consistent rewards without complicated category multipliers.

In contrast, the SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ has a lower base rate of 0.25%, yielding Rs 25 on Rs 10,000 of generic spend. However, it shines in dining and grocery categories where it offers 2.5%, translating to Rs 250 back on Rs 10,000 spent. This makes it an attractive choice for consumers with heavy expenses in these areas, although the benefit is limited to these categories and not on all spend.

Fees Compared

The Canara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured Credit Card ⓘ is entirely free to hold, with no joining or annual fees for life. This makes it a cost-effective option for anyone wary of fees.

On the other hand, the SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ charges Rs 499 as both joining and annual fees. The annual fee is waived if you spend Rs 1 lakh annually, which breaks down to about Rs 8,333 per month. To cover the Rs 499 annual fee purely from the base reward rate, one would need to spend approximately Rs 1,99,600, but considering the higher category rewards on dining and groceries, the break-even could be reached sooner if you spend heavily in those areas.

Which One Should You Pick

Pick the Canara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured Credit Card ⓘ if you want a no-fee credit card that offers decent base rewards and some domestic lounge access. It suits users who prioritize cost savings on fees and want a simple rewards structure without worrying about categories. It is also a fit for those who use UPI-RuPay extensively.

Choose the SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ if you are a first-time cardholder or someone who spends significantly on dining and groceries. Its enhanced rewards in these categories can offset the fees if you meet the Rs 1 lakh annual spend waiver. The card is suitable for shoppers looking to maximize rewards in specific categories.

In conclusion, skip the Canara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured card ⓘ if you want better rewards in dining and grocery or are willing to pay a fee for richer category benefits. Skip the SBI Simplysave card ⓘ if you cannot meet the fee waiver spend or want a completely fee-free card with lounge privileges.

What to Check Before You Apply

  • Verify any caps or maximum rewards on category spends to ensure your high spending is rewarded fully.
  • Confirm the redemption value of points as some cards offer points but with poor conversion rates.
  • Carefully calculate the monthly spend needed to waive the SBI Simplysave card’s fees.
  • Note the forex markup differences; the Canara Bank card charges 3% while SBI charges 3.5%.
  • Check which gates offer lounge access on the Canara Bank card to ensure convenience.

FAQ

What is the annual fee for both cards?+
The Canara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured Credit Card ⓘ has no joining or annual fees for life. The SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ charges Rs 499 for both joining and annual fees, with a waiver if you spend Rs 1 lakh annually.
Which card offers better rewards on general spending?+
The Canara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured Credit Card ⓘ offers a higher base reward rate of 0.5%, giving Rs 50 back on Rs 10,000 spent, compared to SBI Simplysave's 0.25% base rate.
Are there any lounge benefits on these cards?+
The Canara Bank RuPay Platinum Secured Credit Card ⓘ offers 4 domestic lounge visits per year. The SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ does not provide any lounge access.
How much does the forex markup cost on international spends?+
The Canara Bank card charges a 3% forex markup, which would cost Rs 3,000 on Rs 1,00,000 abroad. The SBI Simplysave card charges 3.5%, costing Rs 3,500 on the same amount.
Is the SBI Simplysave card suitable for first-time credit card users?+
Yes, the SBI Simplysave Credit Card ⓘ is positioned as a good first card with category rewards on dining and groceries, plus a welcome benefit of 2,000 reward points on spending Rs 2,000 in the first 60 days.