Quick Verdict

  • The HDFC Bank BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Card ⓘ wins for everyday spend with a superior base reward rate of 3.33% versus 3% on the Times Black ICICI Bank Credit Card ⓘ.
  • For travel and lounge access, both cards offer unlimited domestic and international lounge access, but the HDFC card offers a higher travel reward rate of 16.67% compared to 3% on the ICICI card, making it the better travel companion.
  • The HDFC card is cheaper to hold if you can hit the annual waiver spend of Rs 7.50 lakh (about Rs 62,500 monthly), compared to the ICICI card’s Rs 20,000 fee and no waiver details given.
  • Choose the HDFC BizBlack Metal if you are a business or premium traveler focused on travel rewards and lounges. Pick the Times Black ICICI card if you want additional premium perks like Priority Pass, concierge, and dining benefits despite a higher fee.

Side by Side

DetailHDFC Bank BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Card ⓘTimes Black ICICI Bank Credit Card ⓘ
Annual feeRs 10,000Rs 20,000
Joining feeRs 10,000Rs 20,000
Fee waiver on spendRs 7.50 lakh
Reward rate3.33% base3% base
Reward typepointspoints
Domestic loungeUnlimitedUnlimited
International loungeUnlimitedUnlimited
Forex markup2%2%
Best suited forbusiness, premium, travel, lounge, rewardspremium, travel, lounge, forex, rewards

Rewards Compared

The HDFC Bank BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Card ⓘ offers a base reward rate of 3.33%, which translates to Rs 333 back on every Rs 10,000 spent. This is slightly better than the Times Black ICICI Bank Credit Card ⓘ, which returns Rs 300 on the same spend at a 3% base rate. The standout feature of the HDFC card is its exceptional travel category reward rate of 16.67%, yielding Rs 1,667 back on Rs 10,000 spent on travel, which dwarfs the ICICI card’s 3% travel rate. The ICICI card, however, extends its 3% rewards rate equally across travel, dining, and online categories, providing a more balanced but lower return in these segments.

Both cards use points as their reward currency but differ significantly in category-specific returns, with the HDFC card heavily favoring travel and utilities. This makes the HDFC BizBlack Metal a powerhouse for frequent travelers and utility spenders, while the Times Black ICICI card offers consistent rewards for lifestyle and travel spenders who also want dining and online benefits.

Fees Compared

The HDFC BizBlack Metal card charges Rs 10,000 as both joining and annual fees but waives the annual fee if you spend Rs 7.50 lakh annually, which breaks down to Rs 62,500 monthly. This waiver threshold is relatively high but achievable for serious business or premium users. To cover the Rs 10,000 annual fee purely from the base rewards, you need to spend around Rs 3.00 lakh annually on this card.

The Times Black ICICI card imposes a heftier Rs 20,000 joining and annual fee with no clear waiver condition mentioned. To offset this fee with the base 3% rewards alone, you would need to spend about Rs 6.67 lakh annually, more than double the break-even spend of the HDFC card. Thus, the ICICI card demands a significantly higher commitment to make it cost-effective.

Which One Should You Pick

Choose the HDFC Bank BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Card ⓘ if you are a business user or premium traveler who can leverage the extraordinary 16.67% travel rewards and unlimited lounge access. It suits those who spend heavily on travel and utilities and can meet the Rs 7.50 lakh waiver threshold to avoid fees. It also offers more affordable fees relative to rewards potential, making it ideal for focused, high-spend users.

The Times Black ICICI Bank Credit Card ⓘ is better suited for premium users who value a broader range of perks such as Priority Pass membership, concierge services, dining discounts, and annual memberships like Zomato Gold. Despite its higher fees, it appeals to those who want lifestyle benefits and are willing to pay a premium for them. However, you should only pick this card if you can justify the Rs 20,000 yearly fees with your spending and usage of premium benefits.

In conclusion, if your priority is maximizing travel rewards and keeping fees manageable, go for the HDFC BizBlack Metal. If you seek an elevated lifestyle experience with extensive privileges and can bear the higher fees, Times Black ICICI is the one. Both cards are excellent but serve distinct spender profiles. Avoid the HDFC card if you cannot meet the waiver spend, and skip the ICICI card if you do not need or will not use the premium perks enough to justify its cost.

What to Check Before You Apply

  • Confirm the exact caps or exclusions on high reward categories, especially travel and utilities for HDFC, dining and online for ICICI.
  • Understand the redemption value and flexibility of points for both cards to ensure rewards translate into real value.
  • Carefully calculate the waiver spending math to see if you realistically meet the annual fee waiver thresholds.
  • Check the forex markup percentage and if any forex benefit or waiver applies, since both have a 2% markup.
  • Verify the domestic and international lounge access details, including partner lounges and any guest policies or restrictions.

FAQ

What is the forex markup fee on these cards?+
Both the HDFC Bank BizBlack Metal Edition and Times Black ICICI Bank Credit Cards charge a 2% forex markup on foreign currency transactions.
Are the lounge accesses truly unlimited on both cards?+
Yes, both cards offer unlimited domestic and international lounge access according to issuer listings, though specific lounge partners and guest policies may vary.
Can the annual fee be waived on both cards?+
Only the HDFC BizBlack Metal card offers a clear fee waiver on spending Rs 7.50 lakh annually. The Times Black ICICI card does not specify any fee waiver.
Which card offers better rewards on travel spending?+
The HDFC BizBlack Metal card provides a much higher travel reward rate of 16.67% compared to the 3% offered by the Times Black ICICI card.
Do these cards offer any welcome benefits?+
Yes, the HDFC card comes with Club Marriott Membership and Taj Vouchers worth Rs 5,000, while the ICICI card provides Times Prime and other memberships plus vouchers worth over Rs 20,000.