Quick Verdict

  • The ICICI Bank Rubyx Credit Cardⓘ wins for everyday spend outside fuel, especially in dining and online categories, thanks to its 1% reward rate.
  • The Indianoil RBL Bank Xtra Credit Cardⓘ is the clear winner for fuel spend, offering an 8.5% return at IndianOil stations.
  • The ICICI Rubyx has a higher annual fee by Rs 500 but offers more premium benefits and lounge access.
  • Choose the ICICI Rubyxⓘ if you want a more rounded card for travel, shopping, and rewards; pick the Indianoil RBL Xtraⓘ if your primary spend is on fuel and you want a lower fee.

Side by Side

DetailICICI Bank Rubyx Credit CardⓘIndianoil RBL Bank Xtra Credit Cardⓘ
Annual feeRs 2,000Rs 1,500
Joining feeRs 3,000Rs 1,500
Fee waiver on spendRs 5.00 lakhRs 2.75 lakh
Reward rate0.5% base, 1% dining & online0.4% base, 8.5% fuel, 1% grocery
Reward typepointspoints
Domestic lounge8 per year4 per year
International lounge2 per yearNone
Forex markup3.5%3.5%
Best suited fortravel, rewards, lounge, shoppingfuel, rewards, lounge

Rewards Compared

On a Rs 10,000 spend, the ICICI Bank Rubyx Credit Cardⓘ yields Rs 50 at the base rate. However, if your spend is in dining or online categories, this increases to Rs 100, doubling the effective return. This makes it a good card for those who spend regularly on dining and e-commerce platforms. The welcome benefits also add value but are not part of the ongoing reward rate.

The Indianoil RBL Bank Xtra Credit Cardⓘ offers Rs 40 at the base rate on Rs 10,000 spend, slightly lower than the Rubyx. However, its standout feature is the 8.5% return on fuel spend, which translates to Rs 850 on Rs 10,000 spent at IndianOil stations. Additionally, groceries earn 1%, or Rs 100 per Rs 10,000. This card is tailored for those with significant fuel expenses, making it highly rewarding in that category.

Fees Compared

The ICICI Rubyxⓘ charges a joining fee of Rs 3,000 and an annual fee of Rs 2,000, with a fee waiver if you spend Rs 5.00 lakh annually, which breaks down to about Rs 41,667 per month. The Indianoil RBL Xtraⓘ has lower fees: Rs 1,500 joining and Rs 1,500 annual, waived if you spend Rs 2.75 lakh annually or Rs 22,917 monthly. The Rubyx’s higher fee is justified if you can leverage its premium benefits and higher category rewards. The break-even spend to cover the Rs 500 extra annual fee for Rubyx over Xtra is about Rs 5.00 lakh, which is quite high, so only heavy spenders should consider it.

Which One Should You Pick

Choose the ICICI Bank Rubyx Credit Cardⓘ if you are a frequent traveler who values lounge access and premium benefits like concierge and golf access. It is also suitable if you spend heavily on dining and online shopping, as the 1% category rewards add up well. However, if your annual spend is below Rs 4 lakh, the fees might outweigh the rewards.

The Indianoil RBL Bank Xtra Credit Cardⓘ is ideal for those who spend a significant portion of their budget on fuel, especially at IndianOil stations, where the 8.5% return is unmatched. It also suits users looking for a lower fee card with decent rewards on groceries and some lounge access. Avoid this card if you rarely spend on fuel or want international lounge benefits.

In summary, pick the ICICI Rubyxⓘ for a premium, travel and lifestyle-focused card with better category rewards outside fuel. Opt for the Indianoil RBL Xtraⓘ if fuel spend dominates your expenses and you want to keep fees low.

What to Check Before You Apply

  • Verify the quarterly Rs 75,000 spend gate for domestic lounge access on both cards to ensure you qualify.
  • Understand the redemption process and value of points, especially since both cards use points but have different reward structures.
  • Calculate if your monthly spend meets the fee waiver thresholds: Rs 41,667 for Rubyx and Rs 22,917 for Xtra.
  • Consider the 3.5% forex markup if you plan to use the card abroad; neither card offers a waiver on this fee.

FAQ

What is the forex markup fee on these cards?+
Both the ICICI Bank Rubyx Credit Cardⓘ and the Indianoil RBL Bank Xtra Credit Cardⓘ charge a 3.5% forex markup on foreign currency transactions, which is standard in India.
Can I get lounge access internationally with these cards?+
Only the ICICI Bank Rubyx Credit Cardⓘ offers international lounge access, with 2 visits per year. The Indianoil RBL Bank Xtra Credit Cardⓘ does not provide international lounge access.
How can I waive the annual fee on these cards?+
The ICICI Rubyxⓘ waives the Rs 2,000 annual fee if you spend Rs 5.00 lakh annually, while the Indianoil RBL Xtraⓘ waives its Rs 1,500 fee if you spend Rs 2.75 lakh annually.
Are the welcome benefits valuable on these cards?+
The ICICI Rubyxⓘ offers welcome vouchers worth several thousand rupees across TataCliQ, EaseMyTrip, Croma, and EazyDiner, which can add significant upfront value. The Indianoil RBL Xtraⓘ provides 3,000 fuel points as a welcome benefit, which is beneficial if you use it for fuel.
Is the fuel surcharge waiver applicable on both cards?+
Only the Indianoil RBL Bank Xtra Credit Cardⓘ offers a 1% fuel surcharge waiver up to Rs 200 per month, making it more cost-effective for fuel purchases.