Quick Verdict

  • The Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ wins for everyday spend due to its higher base reward rate of 0.8% compared to 0.25% on the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ.
  • The BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ is the clear winner for fuel purchases with a 4.25% reward rate versus no special fuel rate on the Yes card.
  • The Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ offers domestic lounge access, making it better for lounge users, while the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ has no lounge benefits.
  • Both cards have the same forex markup of 3.5%, but the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ is slightly cheaper to hold with Rs 499 annual and joining fees versus Rs 599 each on the Yes card.
  • Choose the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ if you primarily spend on fuel and want a low-fee first card. Opt for the Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ if your spending is more general, especially on dining and groceries, and you value lounge access.

Side by Side

DetailBPCL SBI Credit CardⓘYes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ
Annual feeRs 499Rs 599
Joining feeRs 499Rs 599
Fee waiver on spendRs 1.00 lakhRs 1.00 lakh
Reward rate0.25% base0.8% base
Reward typepointspoints
Fuel category rate4.25%Not recorded
Online category rate1.25%Not recorded
Dining category rateNot recorded2%
Grocery category rateNot recorded2%
Domestic loungeNone4 per year (Rs 50,000 quarterly spend gate)
International loungeNoneNone
Forex markup3.5%3.5%
Best suited forfuel, first-cardrewards, dining, first-card, lounge, shopping

Rewards Compared

On a Rs 10,000 general spend, the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ earns Rs 25 in rewards at its base rate of 0.25%, while the Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ earns Rs 80 at 0.8%. This makes the Yes card more rewarding for typical everyday purchases excluding categories.

For category spends, the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ shines on fuel with a 4.25% rate, yielding Rs 425 back on Rs 10,000 spent. It also offers 1.25% on online spends. The Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ does not have a fuel category bonus but gives 2% back on dining and groceries, equating to Rs 200 for each Rs 10,000 spent. This means the BPCL card is best for fuel-heavy spenders, while the Yes card benefits those spending on dining and groceries.

Fees Compared

The BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ charges Rs 499 each for joining and annual fees, while the Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ charges Rs 599 for each. Both cards waive fees with Rs 1.00 lakh annual spend, which breaks down to about Rs 8,333 per month.

Considering the higher base reward rate on the Yes card but its Rs 100 higher fees, the break-even spend to justify the extra cost is Rs 18,182 annually. Users spending more than this amount benefit from the Yes card’s better rewards despite the higher fees. Otherwise, the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ is more cost-effective.

Which One Should You Pick

Choose the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ if you are a fuel-focused spender or a first-time credit card user looking for a low-cost card with good fuel rewards. It is not suitable for those who want lounge access or better rewards on dining and groceries.

The Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ suits users who spend broadly on dining, groceries, and shopping, and who value domestic lounge access. It is also a good first card but less ideal if fuel is your main category or if you want the cheapest fees.

Overall, if your spend is mostly fuel, pick the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ. For diversified spending with lounge perks, the Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ is the better choice. Skip the BPCL card if you want lounge access or higher base rewards. Skip the Yes card if you want the lowest fees or focus on fuel.

What to Check Before You Apply

  • Verify any caps on category rewards to ensure your spend qualifies fully.
  • Understand the redemption value of points or vouchers to confirm the effective return.
  • Calculate the monthly spend needed to waive the annual fee and if it fits your budget.
  • Beware of the 3.5% forex markup on foreign transactions, which is standard but costly for frequent travelers.
  • For the Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ, note the Rs 50,000 quarterly spend gate to access domestic lounges.

FAQ

What is the joining and annual fee waiver condition for these cards?+
Both the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ and Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ waive the joining and annual fees if you spend Rs 1.00 lakh annually, which is approximately Rs 8,333 per month.
Do these cards offer lounge access?+
The Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ provides 4 domestic lounge visits per year, subject to spending Rs 50,000 quarterly. The BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ does not offer any lounge access.
Which card offers better rewards on fuel?+
The BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ offers a superior fuel reward rate of 4.25%, making it the best choice for fuel spending. The Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ does not have a fuel category bonus.
How do the forex charges compare?+
Both cards charge a forex markup of 3.5% on foreign currency transactions, which is standard in the Indian credit card market.
Is the Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ better for everyday spending?+
Yes, due to its higher base reward rate of 0.8%, the Yes Prosperity Edge Credit Cardⓘ is more rewarding for general everyday purchases compared to the BPCL SBI Credit Cardⓘ’s 0.25%.