Quick Verdict

  • For everyday spend, the HDFC Bank BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Cardⓘ wins with a much higher effective return rate.
  • For travel and lounge access, the HDFC BizBlack also leads with unlimited domestic and international lounge access and a lower forex markup.
  • The American Express Platinum Reserve Credit Cardⓘ is more expensive to hold without waiver but offers unique premium benefits useful for dining and select luxury experiences.
  • Choose the Amex Platinum Reserve if you prioritize dining discounts, concierge services, and premium hotel memberships; pick the HDFC BizBlack if you want superior rewards on business and travel spend and more lounge visits.

Side by Side

DetailAmerican Express Platinum Reserve Credit CardⓘHDFC Bank BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Cardⓘ
Annual feeRs 10,000Rs 10,000
Joining feeRs 10,000Rs 10,000
Fee waiver on spendRs 7.50 lakh
Reward rate0.5%3.33%
Reward typepointspoints
Domestic lounge8 per yearUnlimited
International loungeNoneUnlimited
Forex markup3.5%2%
Best suited forpremium, dining, rewards, travel, shopping, loungebusiness, premium, travel, lounge, rewards

Rewards Compared

Spending Rs 10,000 on the American Express Platinum Reserve Credit Cardⓘ earns Rs 50 back in effective rewards, reflecting its base reward rate of 0.5%. This card focuses on premium lifestyle benefits rather than high reward rates. In contrast, the HDFC Bank BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Cardⓘ provides Rs 333 back on the same Rs 10,000 spend at the base rate of 3.33%. This is more than six times the return, making it highly rewarding for everyday expenses.

Furthermore, the HDFC BizBlack card shines in its category rates: travel spends earn an astonishing 16.67% return, translating to Rs 1,667 on Rs 10,000 spend, and utilities earn 3.33% or Rs 333. The Amex card lacks category-specific enhanced rates but offers value through other premium benefits.

Fees Compared

Both cards charge Rs 10,000 as joining and annual fees. The HDFC BizBlack card offers a fee waiver if you spend Rs 7.50 lakh annually, which breaks down to about Rs 62,500 monthly. The Amex Platinum Reserve card does not have a fee waiver, meaning you pay the fee regardless of spend. The break-even spend to cover the base reward rate is approximately Rs 20 lakh for the Amex card, much higher than Rs 3 lakh for the HDFC BizBlack, indicating the latter’s rewards can justify the fee at more moderate spending levels.

Which One Should You Pick

Pick the American Express Platinum Reserve Credit Cardⓘ if you are a premium lifestyle spender who values dining discounts, concierge access, and exclusive hotel memberships like ALL Accor+ Explorer. It suits those who enjoy curated luxury benefits and don’t mind paying a fee without a waiver option. Avoid it if you want strong rewards on everyday spend or travel-related perks.

Choose the HDFC Bank BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Cardⓘ if you are a business or frequent traveler looking for excellent reward rates, unlimited lounge access both domestically and internationally, and a lower forex markup. Its fee waiver on Rs 7.50 lakh annual spend makes it less costly for substantial users. Skip this card if you spend less than Rs 62,500 monthly or do not value lounge access highly.

Overall, the HDFC BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Card is the clear winner for most reward-focused users, while the Amex Platinum Reserve suits those chasing premium lifestyle experiences.

What to Check Before You Apply

  • Check if the rewards cap or category restrictions apply beyond the base rates.
  • Confirm the actual redemption value of points as reward_type “points” can vary.
  • Calculate if your monthly spend meets the Rs 62,500 threshold for the HDFC fee waiver.
  • Consider the forex markup cost if you travel internationally and plan foreign currency spending.
  • Verify the lounge locations and access restrictions to ensure they cover your usual airports.

FAQ

What is the forex markup charge on each card?+
The American Express Platinum Reserve Credit Cardⓘ charges a 3.5% forex markup on foreign currency spends, while the HDFC BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Cardⓘ charges a lower 2% markup, making the latter more cost-effective for overseas transactions.
Does the HDFC BizBlack card offer fee waivers?+
Yes, the HDFC BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Cardⓘ waives its Rs 10,000 annual fee if you spend Rs 7.50 lakh or more annually, which is about Rs 62,500 per month. The Amex Platinum Reserve card does not offer any fee waiver.
How many airport lounges do these cards provide access to?+
The HDFC BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Cardⓘ offers unlimited access to over 1,000 lounges domestically and internationally. The Amex Platinum Reserve Credit Cardⓘ provides access to 8 domestic lounges per year but none internationally.
What are the welcome benefits for these cards?+
The Amex Platinum Reserve cardⓘ offers 11,000 bonus Membership Rewards points on spending Rs 30,000 within 90 days, along with other premium memberships. The HDFC BizBlack cardⓘ provides Club Marriott membership and Taj vouchers worth Rs 5,000.
Which card is better for business users?+
The HDFC BizBlack Metal Edition Credit Cardⓘ is better suited for business users due to its higher reward rates on travel and utilities, unlimited lounge access, and fee waiver on substantial spend. The Amex Platinum Reserve cardⓘ is more lifestyle-oriented.