Quick Verdict

  • The Indianoil HDFC Bank Credit Cardⓘ wins for everyday spend with a higher base reward rate of 1% versus 0.5% on the ICICI card.
  • For fuel spend, both cards offer the same 5% return, but the Indianoil HDFC card also rewards groceries at 5%, giving it an edge for varied spending.
  • The ICICI Bank HPCL Coral Credit Cardⓘ is cheaper to hold if you spend less than Rs 1.50 lakh annually, thanks to a lower fee waiver threshold.
  • Choose the ICICI card if you want domestic lounge access and are a fuel-first or shopping-oriented user. Pick the Indianoil HDFC card if you want better base rewards and grocery benefits without lounge needs.

Side by Side

DetailICICI Bank HPCL Coral Credit CardⓘIndianoil HDFC Bank Credit Cardⓘ
Annual feeRs 199Rs 500
Joining feeRs 199Rs 500
Fee waiver on spendRs 1.50 lakhRs 50,000
Reward rate0.5% base, 5% fuel1% base, 5% fuel, 5% grocery
Reward typepointspoints
Domestic lounge4 per year (Rs 75,000 quarterly spend gate)None
International loungeNoneNone
Forex markup3.5%3.5%
Best suited forfuel, first-card, shoppingfuel, first-card, upi-rupay

Rewards Compared

The ICICI Bank HPCL Coral Credit Cardⓘ offers a base reward rate of 0.5%, which translates to Rs 50 back on Rs 10,000 spent. Its standout category is fuel, where it provides a 5% return, or Rs 500 on Rs 10,000 spent on fuel. This makes it a strong choice for fuel spenders but less rewarding on other categories.

In contrast, the Indianoil HDFC Bank Credit Cardⓘ doubles the base reward rate to 1%, yielding Rs 100 on Rs 10,000 spent across all categories. It matches the ICICI card’s 5% fuel return and adds a 5% return on grocery spend as well, also Rs 500 on Rs 10,000. This broader category coverage and higher base rate make it more versatile for everyday spending beyond fuel.

Fees Compared

The ICICI card charges a joining fee and annual fee of Rs 199 each, with a high waiver threshold of Rs 1.50 lakh annually (about Rs 12,500 per month). This means you need to spend Rs 1.50 lakh yearly to avoid fees, which is relatively high but balanced by the low fee amount.

The Indianoil HDFC card has a higher joining and annual fee of Rs 500 each but a much lower waiver threshold of Rs 50,000 annually (around Rs 4,167 per month). This lower waiver spend makes it easier to avoid fees if you spend moderately.

The Indianoil card’s higher base rate comes with an extra Rs 301 annual fee compared to the ICICI card. To justify this, you need to spend about Rs 60,200 more annually to cover the fee difference purely from the base reward rate advantage.

Which One Should You Pick

Choose the ICICI Bank HPCL Coral Credit Cardⓘ if you prioritize domestic lounge access and are primarily a fuel or shopping spender who can meet the Rs 1.50 lakh waiver threshold. It is also suitable as a first credit card for those who want a low fee and some lounge perks. However, skip this card if you want higher base rewards on all spend or grocery rewards.

The Indianoil HDFC Bank Credit Cardⓘ suits users who want a better base reward rate of 1%, plus fuel and grocery category returns, with a lower waiver threshold making it easier to avoid fees. It is ideal for everyday spenders who want to maximize rewards across categories without lounge needs. Avoid this card if you rarely spend Rs 50,000 annually or want lounge access.

Overall, the Indianoil HDFC card edges out for everyday rewards and category breadth, while the ICICI HPCL Coral card appeals to fuel-focused spenders who value lounges and lower fees if they can meet the high waiver spend.

What to Check Before You Apply

  • Confirm the quarterly Rs 75,000 spend gate for domestic lounges on the ICICI card to ensure you can access them.
  • Understand the redemption value of points for both cards, as points are the reward type but conversion rates may vary.
  • Calculate your monthly spend carefully to see if you can meet the fee waiver thresholds: Rs 12,500 for ICICI and Rs 4,167 for Indianoil HDFC.
  • Both cards charge a 3.5% forex markup, so avoid foreign currency spend if you want to minimize fees.
  • Check which airports and lounges are covered by the ICICI card’s domestic lounge access to ensure they match your travel plans.

FAQ

What is the difference in joining and annual fees between these two cards?+
The ICICI Bank HPCL Coral Credit Cardⓘ charges Rs 199 for both joining and annual fees, while the Indianoil HDFC Bank Credit Cardⓘ charges Rs 500 for each.
Which card offers better rewards on fuel spend?+
Both cards offer a 5% return on fuel spend, equating to Rs 500 back on Rs 10,000 spent in this category.
Does either card provide international lounge access?+
No, neither the ICICI Bank HPCL Coral Credit Cardⓘ nor the Indianoil HDFC Bank Credit Cardⓘ offers international lounge access.
How much do I need to spend monthly to waive the annual fee on each card?+
You need to spend Rs 12,500 per month on the ICICI card and Rs 4,167 per month on the Indianoil HDFC card to waive the annual fees.
Are there any benefits beyond rewards and fees that differentiate these cards?+
Yes, the ICICI card offers 4 domestic lounge visits per year with a quarterly spend gate, while the Indianoil HDFC card does not provide lounge access but includes grocery rewards and UPI-RuPay compatibility.